judging system

[The Mast]

Why would there even be title battles if battles aren't judged? Win/Loss records are how you get a shot.

[shaider]

judging is based on the preference of the judge. like i dont like jokes but if i hear one that i would really like then that would be a major plus point.

[yayo403]

they should just have a poll on this site and let the public decide the winner. I watch a battle once and say that guy got killed but when you watch it again you like ah shit this dude went in more then i thought. Anywyas this system would work so there would be no "robbery" match's.

[The Mast]

Polls can be fixed with proxies and shit.

If this site was the place that battles were judged, everyone should be given criteria and be asked to write a decently lengthy post containing all requested judging criteria. Eventually, you can build points up as a judge and, for the more high profile matches, Organik can pick the five top rated judges to participate.

That won't work, though, because people like knowing the winners at the events. It's why they go.

[yayo403]

Polls can be fixed with proxies and shit.

If this site was the place that battles were judged, everyone should be given criteria and be asked to write a decently lengthy post containing all requested judging criteria. Eventually, you can build points up as a judge and, for the more high profile matches, Organik can pick the five top rated judges to participate.

That won't work, though, because people like knowing the winners at the events. It's why they go.

True , but they should let the battlers decide if they wanted it judged there or online . Give a choice

[Ryan Spulecki]

More battlers as judges. Only way to do it. People who catch all the witty bars or references to certain things. That team of Marv/Soul aka Black Thunder/White Lightning, where pretty spot on along with Bowers.

[illipsis]

More battlers as judges. Only way to do it. People who catch all the witty bars or references to certain things. That team of Marv/Soul aka Black Thunder/White Lightning, where pretty spot on along with Bowers.

This...in the Forbes article about WD2 it's mentioned that the concensus of battlers at the event was that they endeavour to appeal to their peers first, then the internet audience and lastly the audience at the venue. So it makes sense that battles should be judged by the people at whom the bars are most directly presented.